157 brands scored from the outside, updated as new audits publish.

















Truly Beauty
trulybeauty.com
“Only a single text pull-quote from 'Jillian M.' is shown near the CTA area. No photo reviews or UGC imagery are visible on the page. The full review section with customer photos, if it exists, is not visible in the screenshots, meaning social proof relies entirely on one anonymous quote near the buy box.”
+11 more findings

MERIT Beauty
meritbeauty.com
“The 'ADD TO CART | $30' button is prominent on mobile but does not appear to be sticky on scroll — no persistent bottom bar is visible in the mobile screenshot. Once a user scrolls into the shade selector or 'The Shades' section, the CTA disappears from view.”
+11 more findings

MooGoo USA
moogoousa.com
“The '$24.90 | ADD TO BAG' button is visible above the fold on mobile but does NOT appear to be sticky on scroll — as the user scrolls down through the accordion sections and cross-sell carousel, there is no persistent CTA bar visible in the mobile screenshot. This means the CTA disappears during the consideration phase.”
+11 more findings

Haus Labs
hauslabs.com
“PSI mobile score is 35/100 with an LCP of 15.9s and TBT of 1,280ms. A 15.9-second largest contentful paint means the majority of first-time mobile visitors on average connections will abandon before the page is usable. This is the single most damaging metric on the page.”
+7 more findings

ICONIC LONDON INC
us.iconiclondoninc.com
“The 'ADD TO BAG - $35.00' CTA is specific and price-inclusive, which is above baseline. On mobile it is visible after scrolling past the shade picker, but there is no sticky add-to-cart bar observed on scroll — the CTA disappears as the user scrolls into the product description and reviews.”
+11 more findings

Glossier
glossier.com
“The 'Add to bag $82' CTA is visible above the fold on mobile and appears as a full-width dark button. However, there is no evidence of a sticky CTA bar on scroll — once the user scrolls past the buy box into the description and bundles section, the button disappears from view.”
+10 more findings

Wildling
wildling.com
“On mobile, the star rating shows '(0 Reviews)' with empty stars — the desktop screenshot correctly shows 4.5 stars and 914 reviews. This is a critical rendering bug: cold mobile visitors see zero social proof at the most trust-sensitive moment.”
+7 more findings

Rajani MD
store.rajanimd.com
“PSI mobile score of 16/100 is catastrophic — LCP of 57.8s means the hero image takes nearly a minute to fully load on a cold mobile visit. TBT of 2,130ms and CLS of 0.231 compound the problem with janky interactivity and layout shift. This alone will kill conversion for a significant share of mobile traffic.”
+7 more findings

cocokind
cocokind.com
“PSI mobile score is 31/100 with LCP of 19.9s and FCP of 6.8s — a cold first-time visitor on mobile waits nearly 7 seconds to see any content and nearly 20 seconds for the main image to load. TBT of 1,200ms means the page is unresponsive to taps for over a second after load. This is a severe drop-off risk before a visitor even reads the product name.”
+7 more findings

ILIA Beauty
iliabeauty.com
“PSI mobile score is 28/100 — LCP of 15.5s and FCP of 6.1s mean a cold first-time visitor on mobile waits over 6 seconds to see any content and over 15 seconds for the main image to load. TBT of 2,030ms indicates heavy main-thread blocking. This is a critical conversion killer for a beauty brand where first impression is everything.”
+7 more findings

Agent Nateur
agentnateur.com
“PSI mobile score is 42/100 — below the 50-point threshold, earning 0 pts on the PSI component. LCP of 4.4s and TBT of 1,870ms are severe: a cold mobile visitor on an average connection will wait over 4 seconds before the largest content element paints, and the page will feel unresponsive for nearly 2 seconds due to main-thread blocking. This directly suppresses add-to-cart conversion for paid traffic.”
+8 more findings

Maelove Skincare
maelove.com
“PSI mobile score is 43/100 — below the 50-point threshold, earning 0 of 10 pts. LCP of 18.8 seconds is critically slow; a first-time cold mobile visitor will see a blank or partially loaded page for nearly 19 seconds. FCP of 5.2 s means even the first paint is delayed. TBT of 570 ms indicates significant main-thread blocking. This is a severe conversion killer for paid traffic.”
+10 more findings

P. Louise Cosmetics USA
p-louise.com
“No return policy or money-back guarantee is shown near the CTA on either mobile or desktop. For a mystery bag where the customer cannot choose what they receive, the absence of a visible satisfaction guarantee or return policy near the buy button is a meaningful trust gap that will suppress conversion.”
+11 more findings

Saltair
saltair.com
“PSI mobile score is 39/100 with an LCP of 27.2s and FCP of 10.9s — catastrophically slow cold load. A first-time mobile visitor waits nearly 11 seconds before seeing any content and over 27 seconds for the hero image to fully render. TBT of 670ms adds significant input delay on top of that.”
+7 more findings

Snow Fox Skincare
snowfoxskincare.com
“PSI mobile score is 30/100 with an LCP of 17.9s and TBT of 1,450ms — a cold first-time visitor on mobile waits nearly 18 seconds for the largest content element to paint. This is a critical conversion killer at the top of the funnel before any copy or imagery even registers.”
+7 more findings

Supergoop!
supergoop.com
“PSI mobile score is 35/100 with an LCP of 21.6 seconds and TBT of 1,640 ms — a cold first-time visitor on mobile waits over 20 seconds for the largest content element to paint. This is a critical conversion killer before the page even renders.”
+7 more findings

Oak Essentials
oakessentials.com
“PSI mobile score is 26/100 with LCP of 12.4s and TBT of 3,360ms — a cold first-time visitor on mobile waits over 12 seconds before the largest content element paints. This is a critical load failure that will cause significant bounce before the page is even readable.”
+7 more findings

SKINN
skinn.com
“PSI mobile score is 37/100 with an LCP of 17.2s and FCP of 7.8s — a cold mobile visitor waits over 7 seconds before seeing any content. TBT of 490ms means the page is unresponsive to taps for nearly half a second after load. CLS of 0.141 causes visible layout shift, likely as images and the subscription widget load in.”
+7 more findings

SAINT JANE
saintjanebeauty.com
“No customer photo reviews or UGC visible anywhere on the page in either screenshot. Text-only reviews (if present) are hidden behind 'See Full Details' or below the fold — no visual social proof to build trust at the point of decision.”
+13 more findings

TIRTIR Official
tirtir.global
“No customer photo reviews or UGC are visible anywhere in the screenshots. No press mentions, 'As Seen In' bar, or named publication badges appear on the page. For a K-beauty brand with likely significant press coverage and social buzz, this is a significant missed trust signal.”
+10 more findings

Milk Makeup
milkmakeup.com
“PSI mobile score is 10/100 — catastrophic. LCP of 71.9s means the hero image takes over a minute to fully load on a cold mobile visit. TBT of 1,450ms and CLS of 0.43 indicate severe layout shift and thread blocking. This is the single biggest conversion killer on the page.”
+7 more findings

SACHEU
sacheu.com
“The 'ADD $14' CTA button is large and dark on mobile, but it is NOT sticky — it appears mid-page and disappears on scroll. There is no persistent sticky add-to-cart bar visible at the bottom of the mobile screenshot as the user scrolls into the 'HOW TO USE' section.”
+11 more findings

grace & stella
graceandstella.com
“PSI mobile score is 13/100. LCP of 38.7s is catastrophic — a first-time mobile visitor waits over 38 seconds for the largest content element to paint. TBT of 1,250ms and CLS of 0.387 compound the problem with heavy interactivity blocking and severe layout shift. The sticky 'ADD TO CART $26.00' bar and the DEWIE AI chat widget are likely major contributors to script bloat.”
+7 more findings

Native
nativecos.com
“The 'ADD TO CART $14.00' button is large and prominent on mobile, but it is NOT sticky — it appears only after scrolling past the full scent-picker grid (12+ scent options visible), meaning a first-time visitor must scroll significantly before the CTA is reachable. No persistent sticky CTA bar is observed on mobile.”
+11 more findings

Brandefy
brandefyskin.com
“PSI mobile score is 40/100 with an LCP of 18.3s and FCP of 5.0s — a cold first-time visitor on mobile waits nearly 18 seconds before the largest content element loads. TBT of 670ms further signals a heavily blocked main thread. This is a critical conversion killer in beauty where bounce rates spike after 3s.”
+7 more findings

ALLIES OF SKIN
us.allies.shop
“PSI mobile score is 20/100. LCP of 15.5s is catastrophic — a cold mobile visitor waits over 15 seconds for the hero image to load. TBT of 4,570ms means the page is essentially frozen for nearly 5 seconds. CLS of 0.248 causes visible layout shift, likely jarring the user as the page settles.”
+7 more findings
Kosas Cosmetics
kosas.com
“No customer photo reviews or UGC are visible anywhere in the screenshots. The page shows no review section with photos, no Instagram grid, and no 'real customer' imagery beyond brand-produced lifestyle shots.”
+15 more findings

Solara Suncare
solarasuncare.com
“PSI mobile score is 46/100 with an LCP of 20.9s and FCP of 9.9s — a cold first-time visitor on mobile waits nearly 10 seconds before seeing any content. TBT of 420ms adds further interaction delay. This is a critical load failure for a beauty brand where first impressions are everything.”
+7 more findings

DRMTLGY
drmtlgy.com
“PSI mobile score is 28/100 with LCP of 19.7s and TBT of 1,790ms — catastrophic load times for a cold mobile visitor. FCP at 6.8s means the page is blank for nearly 7 seconds before anything renders. This alone will kill conversion on paid traffic.”
+7 more findings

Fenty Beauty by Rihanna
fentybeauty.com
“Desktop triggers a full-screen email capture modal ('UNLOCK 15% OFF YOUR NEXT $35+ ORDER') on cold load — this is a real friction event for first-time visitors and obscures the Add to Bag CTA and product imagery entirely until dismissed.”
+11 more findings

Civant
civantskincare.com
“PSI mobile score is 43/100 with an LCP of 20.1s and FCP of 10.1s — a cold mobile visitor waits over 10 seconds before seeing any content. TBT of 510ms adds further interaction delay. This is a critical load failure for a paid-traffic landing page.”
+7 more findings

Piping Rock
pipingrock.com
“The 'Add to Cart' button is visible on mobile but is not sticky — it appears mid-page after scrolling past the image gallery and review snippet. There is no persistent sticky CTA bar observed on mobile scroll, meaning a user who scrolls into product details must scroll back up to purchase.”
+10 more findings

Sand Cloud
shop.sandcloud.com
“The 'ADD TO BAG' button is prominent on mobile but does NOT appear to be sticky on scroll — once the user scrolls past the CTA area, there is no persistent floating button visible in the mobile screenshot. The variant selector shows color swatches clearly with 'Selected Style: Navy Acid Wash' labeled. Shipping clarity is absent — no free shipping threshold or delivery estimate is shown on the product page itself. The '100% Happiness Guaranteed' badge appears below the fold in the trust section but no explicit return policy or money-back guarantee copy is shown near the CTA. A bundle upsell ('Pearl Bundle - 4 Pack, $153.60') is present on the page, earning upsell points.”
+7 more findings

Naples Soap Company
naplessoap.com
“The 'ADD TO BAG' button is prominent on mobile but does not appear to be sticky on scroll — no persistent bottom bar is visible in the mobile screenshot as the user scrolls into the features and reviews sections. This means the CTA disappears as users read reviews.”
+9 more findings

Pipette
pipettebaby.com
“No return policy, satisfaction guarantee, or money-back guarantee is visible near the CTA on either mobile or desktop. The only trust elements near the buy button are the Shop Pay installment line and registry badges. For a $44.97 bundle purchase from a new visitor, the absence of a guarantee is a meaningful friction point.”
+9 more findings

COOLA
coola.com
“The 'Add to Bag' CTA is visible above the fold on mobile and appears as a full-width black button, which is dominant. However, there is no sticky CTA bar visible on scroll in the mobile screenshot — once the user scrolls past the button into the description and ingredient sections, the CTA disappears.”
+9 more findings
Versed Skin
versedskin.com
“The 'ADD TO CART — $15.99' button is prominent on mobile but does not appear to be sticky on scroll — once the user scrolls past the product info section into the ingredient and bundle area, the CTA disappears from view. No persistent sticky bar is visible in the mobile screenshot.”
+10 more findings

Tabu
heytabu.com
“On mobile, '★★★★★ 753 Reviews' is displayed directly below the product title — strong placement and solid review volume (100–999 tier). However, on desktop the review widget shows '0 Reviews' with an empty star bar, suggesting a rendering inconsistency or a different review widget loading state. If desktop visitors see 0 reviews, this is a critical trust failure.”
+11 more findings

Summer Fridays
summerfridays.com
“PSI mobile score is 42/100 with LCP of 9.8s and FCP of 4.8s. A nearly 10-second largest contentful paint means the hero product image loads extremely slowly on a cold mobile visit — a critical drop-off risk before the user even sees the product.”
+11 more findings

Allies of Skin
alliesofskin.com
“PSI mobile score of 22/100 is critical — LCP of 13.0s, TBT of 1,370ms, and CLS of 0.248 mean the page is extremely slow to load and visually unstable on cold mobile visits. This alone will kill conversion before a customer even sees the product.”
+9 more findings

Tata Harper Skincare
tataharperskincare.com
“PSI mobile score is 26/100. LCP of 28.4s and FCP of 6.5s are catastrophic for a cold mobile visitor — the hero product image loads nearly half a minute in. TBT of 3,360ms means the page is essentially frozen on interaction for over 3 seconds. At $248 a unit, slow load directly kills conversion.”
+7 more findings

OneSkin
oneskin.co
“PSI mobile score is 47/100 — below the 50-point threshold, scoring 0 pts on the PSI component. LCP of 12.2 seconds is critically slow; a first-time cold visitor on mobile will stare at a loading screen for over 12 seconds before the largest content element paints. CLS of 0.264 means layout shifts are occurring, which will cause mis-taps on the subscription radio buttons and CTA. FCP at 3.8s means even the first visible content is delayed.”
+8 more findings

Rowe Casa Organics
rowecasaorganics.com
“PSI mobile score is 26/100 with an LCP of 48.8s and FCP of 10.4s — a first-time mobile visitor waits nearly 10 seconds before seeing any content and nearly 49 seconds for the largest element to load. TBT of 1,780ms means the page is heavily blocked during load. This is a critical conversion killer on cold mobile traffic.”
+7 more findings

Well People
wellpeople.com
“Shipping threshold is communicated on-page ('FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $50+ & FREE FULL SIZE GIFT WITH ORDERS $75+') in a dedicated banner below the trust badges. However, no return policy or money-back guarantee is visible near the CTA — it is absent from the product page surface entirely in both screenshots.”
+9 more findings

roe Wellness
roewellness.com
“PSI mobile score is 34/100 with LCP of 10.4s and TBT of 1,120ms. A 10-second largest contentful paint means the majority of cold mobile visitors will bounce before the hero image fully renders. This is the single most damaging conversion issue on the page.”
+7 more findings

MERIT Beauty
meritbeauty.com
“On mobile, the star rating shows '0 Reviews' with empty stars — the 6,966 reviews and 4.5-star rating visible on desktop do not render correctly on mobile. This is a critical trust gap: a cold mobile visitor sees zero social proof near the product title.”
+7 more findings

Skin Balm Apothecary
skinbalmapothecary.com
“No return policy, money-back guarantee, or satisfaction guarantee is visible near the CTA on either mobile or desktop. The 'ADD TO CART' button area shows only the Subscribe & Save option and a Shop Pay installments note — no risk-reversal copy to reduce hesitation at the point of purchase.”
+8 more findings

Educated Mess
educatedmess.com
“Star rating (5 stars) and review count ('17 Reviews') are visible near the product title above the fold on both mobile and desktop — good placement. However, 17 reviews is a very low volume for a beauty serum competing in a crowded category, scoring only 0 pts on the volume sub-dimension.”
+8 more findings

Skinfix USA
skinfix.com
“PSI mobile score is 31/100 with an LCP of 21.2s and TBT of 1,300ms. A 21-second largest contentful paint means the hero product image is loading catastrophically slowly for cold mobile visitors — most will bounce before the page is usable.”
+7 more findings

Pure Good LLC
shoppuregood.com
“Only one product image is visible in both the mobile and desktop screenshots — a single studio shot of the blue bottle against a blue/pink background. No lifestyle imagery, no in-use shots, no model applying the serum, no texture close-ups. This is a significant gap for a $48 beauty serum where tactile and aspirational imagery drives conversion.”
+7 more findings

Eight Saints
eightsaintsskincare.com
“PSI mobile score of 18/100 is catastrophic: LCP of 8.9s means most mobile visitors wait nearly 9 seconds to see the main product image, FCP is 3.2s, TBT is 750ms, and CLS of 0.8 indicates severe layout shift — all well above acceptable thresholds for a beauty DTC page.”
+7 more findings

KimChi Chic Beauty
kimchichicbeauty.com
“The 'ADD TO CART' button is prominent and dark/high-contrast on mobile, but there is no sticky CTA bar visible on scroll — once the user scrolls past the button into the product description, they must scroll back up to purchase. This is a meaningful friction point on mobile.”
+9 more findings

Anua US
anua.com
“The 'ADD TO CART' button is prominent and dark/high-contrast on mobile, appearing above the fold after the product name and price. However, there is no sticky CTA bar visible on scroll — once the user scrolls past the button into the accordion sections, there is no persistent buy button in the mobile screenshot.”
+9 more findings

Everyday Oil
everydayoil.com
“The image carousel shows dot indicators suggesting 5+ images, but every visible image is a studio product shot of the amber bottle on a neutral background. No lifestyle imagery — no skin, no person using the oil, no in-context setting — is visible in either screenshot. For a sensory skincare product, the absence of lifestyle photography is a significant missed selling opportunity.”
+10 more findings

Beekman 1802
beekman1802.com
“PSI mobile score is 27/100. LCP of 24.4s and FCP of 6.3s are catastrophic for cold mobile visitors — the page is effectively blank for over 6 seconds. TBT of 2,190ms means the main thread is heavily blocked, making the page feel unresponsive even after it loads.”
+7 more findings

Tubby Todd Bath Co.
tubbytodd.com
“PSI mobile score is 5/100. LCP of 23.5s and FCP of 8.3s mean most first-time mobile visitors will stare at a blank or partially loaded screen for 8+ seconds before seeing content. CLS of 0.905 indicates severe layout shift — elements visibly jump as the page loads. TBT of 1,420ms signals the main thread is heavily blocked, making the page feel unresponsive to taps.”
+7 more findings

Omnilux LED
omniluxled.com
“PSI mobile score is 27/100 with an LCP of 20.1s and FCP of 9.5s — a cold first-time mobile visitor waits over 9 seconds before seeing any content. TBT of 2,230ms means the page is heavily blocked during load. This is a critical conversion killer for a $95 product.”
+7 more findings

Soko Glam
sokoglam.com
“The 'Real AF Guarantee' is referenced in a trust bar at the bottom of the mobile screenshot but is cut off and not legible. No money-back guarantee or return policy language is shown near the CTA. There is no subscribe-and-save toggle, bundle upsell, or 'frequently bought together' module visible on the product page itself.”
+9 more findings

essence makeup
essencemakeup.com
“No video content — no autoplay loop, no before/after demo, no embedded tutorial. For a mascara product where the application result is the entire purchase driver, the absence of video is a significant missed opportunity.”
+10 more findings

Bliss World
blissworld.com
“PSI mobile score is 33/100 with an LCP of 14.8s and TBT of 1,210ms. A 14.8-second largest contentful paint means the hero product image is loading nearly 15 seconds after the page is requested on a cold mobile visit — most users will bounce before the page is usable.”
+7 more findings

BREAD BEAUTY SUPPLY
breadbeautysupply.com
“PSI mobile score is 34/100 with an LCP of 8.7s and a catastrophic TBT of 19,450ms — the page is effectively frozen for nearly 20 seconds on a cold mobile load. This alone will kill conversion for a significant share of first-time visitors.”
+7 more findings
Tatcha
tatcha.com
“PSI mobile score is 21/100. LCP of 17.0s and FCP of 5.5s are catastrophic for a cold mobile visitor — the hero image and product name take over 17 seconds to fully render. TBT of 1,810ms means the page is essentially unresponsive for nearly 2 seconds after load. CLS of 0.166 causes visible layout shift, likely jarring on first view.”
+7 more findings

Brush On Block
brushonblock.com
“PSI mobile score is 27/100 with LCP of 24.9s and TBT of 2,000ms. A 25-second largest contentful paint means most cold mobile visitors will bounce before the page is usable. FCP at 9.4s is also critically slow.”
+7 more findings

COSRX Official
cosrx.com
“No press mentions, 'As Seen In' bar, or named certifications are visible anywhere on the page. COSRX is a well-known K-beauty brand with significant press coverage, but none of it is surfaced here.”
+11 more findings

Julep Beauty
julep.com
“PSI mobile score is 6/100 — catastrophic. LCP of 25.2s means most mobile visitors will abandon before the page finishes loading. CLS of 0.925 indicates severe layout shift, and TBT of 1,240ms signals a heavily blocked main thread. The 'Add To Bag' button is in the lower thumb zone on mobile, and body text is legible, earning partial UX credit, but the load experience is effectively broken.”
+7 more findings

Beauty of Joseon
beautyofjoseon.com
“The 'ADD TO CART' button is visible above the fold on mobile and appears sticky on scroll based on the layout, which is positive. However, there is no free shipping threshold, delivery estimate, or return/money-back guarantee shown near the CTA — these trust signals are absent from the purchase zone entirely.”
+9 more findings

The Daily Essential Co.
thedailyessentialco.com
“PSI mobile score is 33/100 with an LCP of 24.9s and FCP of 8.2s — a cold first-time visitor on mobile waits nearly 25 seconds before the largest content element loads. TBT of 1,070ms indicates heavy main-thread blocking. This is a critical conversion killer before the page is even seen.”
+9 more findings

Evereden
ever-eden.com
“The overall rating '4.63 / 5 from 200 reviews' appears only far below the fold — well past the ingredients table, bundle offer, and multiple accordion sections. There is no star rating or review count displayed near the product title above the fold on mobile or desktop. This buries the strongest trust signal on the page.”
+8 more findings
Topicals
mytopicals.com
“A '4.9 ★' star rating is visible near the product title on both mobile and desktop, but there is NO review count displayed next to it — just the star and number. Without a review count, the rating carries minimal trust weight for a cold visitor who cannot verify how many people rated it.”
+9 more findings

The INKEY List
theinkeylist.com
“Cold mobile visitors are hit with a stacked double-overlay: a region/currency selector ('WHERE ARE YOU SHOPPING?') fires first, and on desktop a separate full-screen email capture ('WOULD YOU LIKE 15% off YOUR FIRST ORDER?') also appears. Two sequential interstitials before a visitor can even evaluate the product create significant friction and delay purchase intent.”
+7 more findings

Good Beauty
goodbeauty.com
“Star rating (5 stars) and review count (56 reviews) are visible near the product title on both mobile and desktop — good placement. However, 56 reviews falls in the 11–99 tier, earning only 2 of 4 possible volume points. No customer photo reviews or UGC are visible anywhere on the page screenshots.”
+12 more findings

Jayda Cheaves Beauty
jaydacheavesbeauty.com
“The sticky 'Add to bag' bar at the bottom of mobile (showing '$85.00' + 'Add to bag') is present and functional — this is a positive. However, there is no shipping clarity on the product page itself beyond the top announcement bar ('free shipping on orders $75+'), and no return policy, money-back guarantee, or satisfaction promise is shown anywhere near the CTA. A cold visitor has no reassurance before committing $85.”
+8 more findings

Onekind
onekind.us
“Star rating (5 stars) and review count (9 reviews) are visible near the product title on both mobile and desktop — above the fold on desktop, just below the fold on mobile after scrolling past the image carousel. Only 9 reviews is critically low volume for a beauty product; this actively undermines trust rather than building it.”
+9 more findings

Toups and Co Organics
toupsandco.com
“No customer photo reviews or UGC are visible anywhere on the page in either screenshot. No press mentions, 'As Seen In' bar, or named certifications (e.g., EWG Verified, USDA Organic) appear on the product page. For a clean beauty brand at a premium price point, this is a significant trust gap.”
+9 more findings

r.e.m. beauty
rembeauty.com
“Star rating (4.7 on mobile, 4.6 on desktop) and review count are shown near the product title above the fold, which is good placement. However, no actual review count number is displayed — only the star rating is visible. Without a review count, trust signal is weakened.”
+15 more findings

Mad Hippie
madhippie.com
“PSI mobile score is 29/100 with an LCP of 17.0 seconds and TBT of 25,410 ms — catastrophically slow. A first-time cold visitor on mobile will stare at a blank or partially loaded screen for 17 seconds before the hero image renders. This alone will kill a significant share of paid traffic.”
+7 more findings

innisfree
us.innisfree.com
“PSI mobile score is 26/100 with LCP of 11.5s, FCP of 4.4s, TBT of 1,690ms, and CLS of 0.127. A cold first-time mobile visitor waits over 11 seconds to see the main product image — a catastrophic load experience that will bleed traffic before a single product element renders.”
+7 more findings

SINCERELY YOURS
sincerely-yours.com
“The 'ADD TO CART $16' button is visible on mobile but does not appear to be sticky on scroll — below the fold, no persistent CTA bar is observed in the mobile screenshot. A first-time visitor scrolling through the lifestyle imagery and benefit copy has no one-tap path back to purchase.”
+8 more findings

Westman Atelier
westman-atelier.com
“PSI mobile score is 26/100 with an LCP of 49.6s and TBT of 2,510ms — catastrophically slow cold load. A first-time mobile visitor waits nearly 50 seconds for the largest content element to paint. This alone will kill conversion before the page is even seen.”
+7 more findings

Kate McLeod
katemcleod.com
“PSI mobile score is 27/100. LCP of 35.3s is catastrophic — a first-time mobile visitor waits over 35 seconds for the largest content element to paint. TBT of 2,490ms means the page is essentially unresponsive for nearly 2.5 seconds after load. FCP of 4.8s means even the first visible content is delayed. This will cause significant bounce before the product is ever seen.”
+7 more findings

Naturium
naturium.com
“PSI mobile score is 27/100 with LCP of 13.5s, FCP of 6.7s, and TBT of 2,320ms. A cold first-time mobile visitor waits nearly 7 seconds before seeing any content and over 13 seconds for the main image to load — catastrophic for a beauty brand competing on visual appeal.”
+7 more findings

Magic Hour
clubmagichour.com
“PSI mobile score is 19/100. LCP of 11.3s and FCP of 6.1s are catastrophic for cold mobile visitors — most users will bounce before the page renders. TBT of 3,160ms means the page is essentially frozen for 3+ seconds after load. CLS of 0.161 also causes visible layout shift.”
+7 more findings

Catrice Cosmetics
catricecosmetics.com
“PSI mobile score is 13/100 with LCP of 20.5s, FCP of 6.2s, CLS of 0.473, and TBT of 1,010ms. A 20-second largest contentful paint means most cold mobile visitors will bounce before the product image even loads. The loyalty popup ('Join our Beauty Squad') likely contributes to blocking render time.”
+7 more findings

Nimi Skincare
nimiskincare.com
“PSI mobile score is 31/100 with an LCP of 16.9s and FCP of 7.1s — a cold mobile visitor waits nearly 7 seconds before seeing any content and over 16 seconds for the hero image to fully load. TBT of 1,170ms means the page is heavily blocked during load. This is a critical conversion killer for a $112 bundle.”
+7 more findings

byAVA
byava.co
“The 'ADD TO CART' button is visible above the fold on mobile and appears to be a full-width prominent button. However, there is no evidence of a sticky CTA bar on scroll — as the user scrolls through the long description and UGC section, the button disappears from view with no persistent bottom bar.”
+9 more findings

Tarte Cosmetics
tartecosmetics.com
“Only 4 reviews are shown with a 4.5-star rating — this is critically low review volume for a beauty brand at $42. The review count is visible near the fold, but 4 reviews provides almost no social validation for a first-time visitor.”
+7 more findings

Public Goods
publicgoods.com
“There is no hero value proposition or tagline — the description copy ('A lightweight conditioner formulated to hydrate, detangle, and support the hair without heaviness') is buried below the fold inside a collapsed accordion on mobile. Nothing above the fold answers 'why this conditioner over any other.'”
+9 more findings

Micro Ingredients
microingredients.com
“The 'ADD TO CART' button is visible on mobile but is not sticky — it does not persist on scroll. The mobile bottom navigation bar (Home, Cart, Products) is sticky, but the ATC button itself disappears as the user scrolls down through the subscription options and legal copy. A sticky ATC bar is absent.”
+11 more findings

Acure
acure.com
“Only 1 review is visible — the star rating shows '5.0 (1) REVIEWS' both on mobile and desktop. A single review provides almost no social validation for a first-time visitor and can actually raise skepticism rather than build trust. No photo reviews, no UGC, and no press mentions or 'As Seen In' bar are visible anywhere on the page.”
+7 more findings

Glow Recipe
glowrecipe.com
“Zero star ratings or review count visible anywhere on the page — neither near the product title nor below the fold. No press mentions, 'As Seen In' bar, or named certifications observed. The only social signal is '✨ 70 people have added this product to cart,' which is a weak urgency nudge, not trust-building proof.”
+7 more findings

Phoebe's Diary
phoebes-diary.com
“Star rating (5.0) and review count (3) are visible near the product title on both mobile and desktop, which is good placement. However, only 3 reviews total is critically low social proof for an $85 product — this signals a very new or under-reviewed listing and will erode trust at the moment of decision.”
+8 more findings

Health Ranger Store
healthrangerstore.com
“Only 2 product images are visible in the thumbnail strip (a front-label shot and a secondary angle). No lifestyle imagery showing the product in use, on a person, or in a wellness context. The desktop 'About' section shows a lifestyle photo of a woman outdoors, but this is far below the fold and not part of the image gallery.”
+11 more findings

Wonder Valley
welcometowondervalley.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Lakota Made
lakotamade.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

delilah Cosmetics US
us.delilahcosmetics.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Skin Gym
skingymco.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Dr. Berg
shop.drberg.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Furtuna Skin
furtunaskin.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Skin Type Solutions
skintypesolutions.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.
Starface World
starface.world
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

100% PURE
100percentpure.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Mount Lai
mountlai.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Alastin USA
alastin.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Olaplex
olaplex.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Sigma Beauty
sigmabeauty.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Kulfi Beauty
kulfibeauty.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Vegan America (product by Rawmantic Chocolate)
vegan-america.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Odacité
odacite.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

BUXOM
buxomcosmetics.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Kaja Beauty
kajabeauty.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Counter
counter.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Lucin Organics
lucinorganics.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

SkincareEssentials
skincareessentials.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

RMS Beauty
rmsbeauty.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

RANAVAT
ranavat.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.
Makeup By Mario
makeupbymario.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Emme Diane
emmediane.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Nudestix
nudestix.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Badger
badgerbalm.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Image Skincare
imageskincare.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.
Hero Cosmetics
herocosmetics.us
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Mented Cosmetics
mentedcosmetics.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

PAT McGRATH LABS
patmcgrath.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Prequel
prequelskin.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

The Natural Faces
thenaturalfaces.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

The Body Deli
thebodydeli.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

YISE Beauty
yisebeauty.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

ColourPop
colourpop.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.
YISE Beauty by Molly Sims
ysebeauty.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Rare Beauty
rarebeauty.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Mosaique
mosaique.skin
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Rare Beauty
rarebeauty.com
Underperforming
Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Mario Badescu
mariobadescu.com
Critical issues identified
Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

Juvia's Place
juviasplace.com
Critical issues identified
Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

GNMart
gnmart.com
Critical issues identified
Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

Free Living Co
shop.freelivingco.co
Critical issues identified
Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

LANSHIN
lanshin.com
Critical issues identified
Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

Montalvan Dermatology
montalvandermatology.com
Critical issues identified
Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.
Kylie Cosmetics
kyliecosmetics.com
Critical issues identified
Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

Function of Beauty
functionofbeauty.com
Critical issues identified
Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

GingerChi
gingerchi.com
Critical issues identified
Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.