The Scoreboard

Every brand, scored.

82 brands scored from the outside, updated as new audits publish.

Pelsbarn page

Pelsbarn

pelsbarn.org

Pet
79/ 100 · Solid
Modkat page

Modkat

modkat.com

Pet
72/ 100 · Solid
Badlands Ranch page

Badlands Ranch

badlandsranch.com

Pet
71/ 100 · Solid
Finn page

Finn

petfinn.com

Pet
70/ 100 · Solid
DIGGS page

DIGGS

diggs.pet

Pet
70/ 100 · Solid
Farm To Pet page

Farm To Pet

farmtopettreats.com

Pet
68/ 100 · Average

PSI mobile score is 30/100 with an LCP of 19.5s and FCP of 6.3s. TBT of 1,330ms indicates severe main-thread blocking. A cold first-time mobile visitor will stare at a blank or partially loaded screen for over 6 seconds before seeing any content — this is a critical conversion killer.

+7 more findings

Repounce page

Repounce

repounce.com

Pet
68/ 100 · Average

A full-screen email-capture modal ('Free Forever Prey™ feather toy with your Order') fires on cold load, covering the product page and the Add to Cart button. This is a real friction event for every first-time visitor — they must dismiss it before they can buy.

+10 more findings

Pupford page

Pupford

pupford.com

Pet
68/ 100 · Average

PSI mobile score is 33/100 with an LCP of 67.8s and TBT of 1,080ms — catastrophically slow cold load. A first-time mobile visitor will stare at a blank or partially loaded screen for over a minute before the largest content element renders. This alone will kill conversion for paid traffic.

+7 more findings

Newton Baby page

Newton Baby

newtonbaby.com

Pet
67/ 100 · Average

The 'ADD TO CART - $299.99' button is visible on mobile without scrolling past the variant selectors, and a sticky CTA behavior is implied by the layout, but the mobile screenshot shows the button is mid-page after variant selection — not confirmed sticky on scroll. Shipping clarity is present ('Ships FREE* in 2-4 business days') directly above the CTA. No return policy or money-back guarantee is visible near the CTA on mobile — this is absent above the fold.

+8 more findings

Open Farm page

Open Farm

openfarmpet.com

Pet
67/ 100 · Average

The 'TRY ONE TIME' CTA button is large, green, and dominant on mobile. However, it is NOT sticky — it disappears as the user scrolls down to the 'YOU MAY ALSO LIKE' section and product description. A sticky Add to Cart bar is absent, meaning users who scroll past the purchase block must scroll back up to buy.

+8 more findings

HubertPet page

HubertPet

hubertpet.com

Pet
67/ 100 · Average

The 'Add to cart' button is visible on mobile but is NOT sticky — it does not persist as the user scrolls. Once the user scrolls past the variant selectors, the CTA disappears and requires scrolling back up or all the way down. This is a meaningful friction point on mobile.

+8 more findings

Happy Staffy Co page

Happy Staffy Co

us.happystaffyco.com

Pet
67/ 100 · Average

The 'PRE-ORDER MY BUNDLE' CTA is prominent above the fold on mobile and a sticky '$69.00 · BUY NOW' bar is visible at the bottom of the desktop screenshot — good sticky behavior. However, the pre-order status ('This product is now on pre-order and is shipping from 20th of June') is shown in small red text below the CTA, which is a significant friction point: a first-time visitor may not notice the delayed shipping and feel deceived post-purchase. This should be surfaced more prominently.

+7 more findings

Leo's Paw page

Leo's Paw

leospaw.com

Pet
66/ 100 · Average

PSI mobile score is 37/100 with LCP of 16.9s and FCP of 7.4s — a cold first-time mobile visitor waits nearly 17 seconds to see the main image. TBT of 810ms means the page is unresponsive to taps for nearly a second after load. This is a critical conversion killer for paid traffic.

+7 more findings

2 Dogs Treats page

2 Dogs Treats

2dogstreats.com

Pet
66/ 100 · Average

No return policy, satisfaction guarantee, or money-back guarantee is visible near the CTA on either mobile or desktop. This is a meaningful trust gap for a first-time pet owner considering a new treat brand.

+10 more findings

Bedsure page

Bedsure

bedsurehome.com

Pet
66/ 100 · Average

On mobile, the 'Add to cart' button is not sticky — it appears inline after the variant selectors and is not visible once the user scrolls into the description section. There is no persistent bottom bar CTA observed in the mobile screenshot.

+8 more findings

Wilderdog page

Wilderdog

wilderdog.com

Pet
65/ 100 · Average

The 'ADD TO CART' button is a full-width black button visible on mobile without scrolling, but it does NOT appear to be sticky on scroll — once the user scrolls past the variant selectors, the CTA disappears and there is no persistent floating button observed in the mobile screenshot. This forces users to scroll back up to purchase.

+11 more findings

Cattasaurus page

Cattasaurus

cattasaurus.com

Pet
64/ 100 · Average

PSI mobile score is 14/100. LCP of 28.3s and FCP of 7.5s mean most first-time mobile visitors will stare at a blank or partially loaded screen for several seconds before seeing any content. CLS of 0.469 causes significant layout shift as assets load, and TBT of 890ms makes the page feel unresponsive to taps.

+7 more findings

Jinx page

Jinx

thinkjinx.com

Pet
64/ 100 · Average

PSI mobile score is 36/100 — a critical failure. LCP of 22.8 seconds means the largest content element takes nearly 23 seconds to load on a cold mobile visit. TBT of 1,050 ms indicates significant main thread blocking. This will cause the majority of cold mobile visitors to abandon before the page is interactive.

+8 more findings

Muddy Mat® page

Muddy Mat®

muddymats.com

Pet
64/ 100 · Average

The size selector on mobile requires scrolling through 30+ size options displayed as a large grid of buttons, which is overwhelming and creates decision paralysis. There is no size guide link visible to help customers choose the right size for their doorway or space.

+10 more findings

Rocco & Roxie Supply Co. page

Rocco & Roxie Supply Co.

roccoandroxie.com

Pet
63/ 100 · Average

PSI mobile score is 27/100 — LCP of 27.4s and FCP of 13.1s are catastrophic for cold mobile visitors. TBT of 1,990ms means the page is essentially frozen for nearly 2 seconds after load. This will cause significant bounce before the page is even interactive.

+7 more findings

Earth Rated page

Earth Rated

earthrated.com

Pet
63/ 100 · Average

PSI mobile score is 25/100. LCP of 22.2s and FCP of 9.6s are catastrophic for cold mobile visitors — the page is effectively blank for nearly 10 seconds on first load. TBT of 3,650ms means the page is unresponsive to taps for over 3 seconds after it appears. This will cause significant bounce before any product content is seen.

+7 more findings

Tuft & Paw page

Tuft & Paw

tuftandpaw.com

Pet
63/ 100 · Average

Star rating (5 stars) and review count ('12 Reviews') are visible near the product title above the fold on both mobile and desktop — good placement. However, 12 reviews is a critically low volume for a product in a competitive pet accessories category. It signals a new or under-reviewed listing and will erode trust for cold visitors.

+9 more findings

Native Pet page

Native Pet

nativepet.com

Pet
63/ 100 · Average

PSI mobile score is 29/100 — critically poor. LCP of 11.9 seconds means the main product image takes nearly 12 seconds to fully load on a cold mobile visit. TBT of 3,820 ms indicates severe JavaScript blocking. FCP of 3.5 s means even the first paint is slow. This will cause significant bounce rates among cold mobile traffic, which is likely the majority of their paid social audience.

+7 more findings

maxbone page

maxbone

maxbone.com

Pet
62/ 100 · Average

Star rating (5 stars) and review count (103 Reviews) are visible near the product title on both mobile and desktop — good placement. However, 103 reviews earns only 3 pts on the volume scale (100–999 range). No customer photo reviews or UGC are visible in the screenshots, and no press mentions or 'As Seen In' bar appears anywhere on the page. The 'Recommended by DogFoodAdvisor' badge on the product bag image is the only third-party signal, but it's embedded in the packaging art rather than called out as a trust element on the page.

+7 more findings

Natural Farm Pet page

Natural Farm Pet

naturalfarmpet.com

Pet
62/ 100 · Average

PSI mobile score is 55/100 with an LCP of 14.0 seconds and FCP of 5.4 seconds. These are critically slow load times — a 14-second LCP means the hero product image takes 14 seconds to fully render on a cold mobile load, which will cause significant bounce rates among first-time visitors on average mobile connections.

+8 more findings

Furbo page

Furbo

furbo.com

Pet
61/ 100 · Average

The primary CTA 'Subscribe now – $137.92' is subscription-gated — there is no visible standalone 'Add to Cart' or one-time purchase button above the fold on mobile. The page forces visitors into a subscription plan selection (Standard vs. Yearly) before they can buy, which adds cognitive load and may alienate users who want a simple purchase. The subscription pricing ($6.99/mo billed at $83.92) alongside the hardware price ($54) creates a confusing dual-price presentation.

+8 more findings

The Honest Kitchen page

The Honest Kitchen

thehonestkitchen.com

Pet
61/ 100 · Average

The 'Add subscription to bag' CTA button is prominent and red on mobile, appearing within thumb reach. However, there is no sticky add-to-cart bar visible on scroll in the mobile screenshot — once the user scrolls past the CTA into the accordion sections (Ingredients, Nutrition, Life Stages, How Much to Feed), the button disappears and requires scrolling back up.

+7 more findings

The Dog Bakery page

The Dog Bakery

thedogbakery.com

Pet
61/ 100 · Average

The 'ADD TO CART' button is visible on mobile without scrolling and appears in a red/coral color that contrasts adequately. However, there is no sticky CTA bar observed on scroll — once the user scrolls past the button into the product description and video, the CTA disappears and requires scrolling back up to purchase.

+11 more findings

One Fast Cat page

One Fast Cat

onefastcat.com

Pet
60/ 100 · Average

The 'Add to Cart' button is visible in the mobile screenshot but it sits below the product description, variant selectors, and 'Complete the look' upsell section — requiring significant scroll before reaching it. No sticky add-to-cart bar is visible on mobile scroll.

+12 more findings

The Honest Kitchen page

The Honest Kitchen

thehonestkitchen.com

Pet
60/ 100 · Average

Product name 'Instant Beef Bone Broth with Turmeric' is visible below the fold on mobile — the image carousel and thumbnail strip push it down, requiring a scroll before the name and price appear.

+12 more findings

Spark Paws page

Spark Paws

sparkpaws.com

Pet
59/ 100 · Average

PSI mobile score is 33/100 — LCP of 9.3 seconds and TBT of 1,290 ms are critically poor. A first-time cold mobile visitor will wait over 9 seconds to see the main product image, which will cause significant bounce before any conversion opportunity.

+8 more findings

Free the Ocean page

Free the Ocean

shop.freetheocean.com

Pet
57/ 100 · Average

No video content is present anywhere on the page — no autoplay loop, no embedded video, no video thumbnail. For a product that replaces paper towels and has an eco-mission story, a short demo video would significantly increase conversion.

+11 more findings

Tomlinson's Feed page

Tomlinson's Feed

tomlinsons.com

Pet
57/ 100 · Average

PSI mobile score is 40/100 with LCP of 19.5 seconds and FCP of 4.7 seconds. A 19.5s LCP means most mobile visitors on average connections will see a blank or partially loaded page for nearly 20 seconds — catastrophic for cold-traffic conversion.

+11 more findings

Wild One page

Wild One

wildone.com

Pet
57/ 100 · Average

No customer photo reviews, UGC imagery, or press/media mentions ('As Seen In' bar) are visible anywhere on the page in either screenshot. No named certifications or trust badges beyond the generic ShopPay installment note. This is a significant gap for a brand in a competitive pet accessories market.

+9 more findings

AFP (All For Paws) page

AFP (All For Paws)

allforpaws.com

Pet
56/ 100 · Average

Zero star ratings or review count visible anywhere on the page — not near the product title, not below the fold. No press mentions, 'As Seen In' bar, or named certifications observed. The only trust signal is a row of payment method icons. This is the single biggest conversion killer on the page.

+7 more findings

Best Friends Store page

Best Friends Store

shop.bestfriends.org

Pet
56/ 100 · Average

The 'Add to Cart' CTA button is orange and prominent on mobile, but it is NOT sticky — once the user scrolls past it into the description, the button disappears entirely. There is no persistent sticky CTA bar on mobile scroll, meaning the user must scroll back up to purchase.

+9 more findings

Catenary Home page

Catenary Home

catenaryhome.com

Pet
55/ 100 · Average

Product name 'Relish | Build Your Dining Set' is visible above the fold on mobile, but the price shows '$0.00 — No items added!' which is confusing and may read as free or broken to a cold visitor who hasn't yet interacted with the bundle builder.

+11 more findings

Blue Q page

Blue Q

blueq.com

Pet
55/ 100 · Average

Star rating (5 stars) and review count '(1)' are visible near the product title on both mobile and desktop — but only 1 review exists. This is actively damaging: a single review signals an untested product and provides no meaningful social proof volume.

+11 more findings

Bocce's Bakery page

Bocce's Bakery

boccesbakery.com

Pet
55/ 100 · Average

Only a single hero image is visible across both mobile and desktop screenshots — a flat lay of five treat bags on a beige background. There are no lifestyle shots of dogs eating the treats, no in-use context, and no video content anywhere on the page.

+11 more findings

Dogbed4less page

Dogbed4less

dogbed4less.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

K9 Ballistics page

K9 Ballistics

k9ballistics.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Health Extension page

Health Extension

healthextension.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

uahpet page

uahpet

uahpet.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

pidan page

pidan

pidan.store

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

PetsVet Supply page

PetsVet Supply

petsvetsupply.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Cat Estate Plus page

Cat Estate Plus

catestateplus.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

PawsPik page

PawsPik

pawspik.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

PetSnowy page

PetSnowy

shop.petsnowy.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

CordaRoy's Convertible Bean Bags page

CordaRoy's Convertible Bean Bags

cordaroys.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

PrettyLitter page

PrettyLitter

account.prettylitter.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Meowvo page

Meowvo

zct104-nq.myshopify.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Sheer Fun For Cats page

Sheer Fun For Cats

sheer-fun-for-cats.myshopify.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Redbarn Pet Products page

Redbarn Pet Products

redbarn.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

PetWiseBrands page

PetWiseBrands

petwisebrands.myshopify.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Ruggable page

Ruggable

shop.ruggable.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Purrs and Whiskers page

Purrs and Whiskers

purrsandwhiskers.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Bully Beds page

Bully Beds

bullybeds.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Embark Vet page

Embark Vet

embarkvet.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Woolbuddy page

Woolbuddy

woolbuddy.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

The Luminous Pets page

The Luminous Pets

theluminouspets.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Nestoly page

Nestoly

nestoly.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Paw Puppets page

Paw Puppets

pawpuppets.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Simply B Vermont page

Simply B Vermont

simplybvermont.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

CatnipTakeout page

CatnipTakeout

catniptakeout.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Jackson Galaxy page

Jackson Galaxy

jacksongalaxy.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Made In Washington page

Made In Washington

madeinwashington.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Pusheen Shop page

Pusheen Shop

shop.pusheen.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Catalyst Pet page

Catalyst Pet

catalystpet.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Cat Amazing page

Cat Amazing

catamazing.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

BARK page

BARK

bark.co

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

MODERNBEAST page

MODERNBEAST

modernbeast.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Shameless Pets page

Shameless Pets

shamelesspets.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

Pawsonify page

Pawsonify

pawsonify.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

The Cat Connection page

The Cat Connection

thecatconnection.com

Pet

Underperforming

Below benchmark for this vertical. Full teardown available on request.

My Three Cats & Co. page

My Three Cats & Co.

mythreecats.com

Pet

Critical issues identified

Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

Wild Earth page

Wild Earth

wildearth.com

Pet

Critical issues identified

Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

FMS Dog Beds page

FMS Dog Beds

fmsdogbeds.com

Pet

Critical issues identified

Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

Lonestar Dog Treats page

Lonestar Dog Treats

lonestartreatsaz.com

Pet

Critical issues identified

Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

Fable Pets page

Fable Pets

fablepets.com

Pet

Critical issues identified

Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

New England Naturals page

New England Naturals

newenglandnaturals.net

Pet

Critical issues identified

Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

Petcetera NOLA page

Petcetera NOLA

petceteranola.com

Pet

Critical issues identified

Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.

Tolonen Family Pet Shop page

Tolonen Family Pet Shop

tolonenfamilypet.com

Pet

Critical issues identified

Significant conversion barriers found. Request the teardown for details.